Three cookies came, but only one was crowned Buffalo's Best Christmas Cookie and walked away with a huge gift basket from Muscoreil's in North Tonawanda. The winning cookie was the Sea Salt and Caramel Treasures made by Tammy Comerate.

Thank you also to our runners up: Kendra Catalano and her Scotch Nog Stars and Donna Frost for her Heavenly Cutout Cookies for coming out and cooking with us! Check out all the deliciousness!

More From The New 96.1 WTSS